What was said
On 12 November 2026 the Spanish outlet Moncloa reported remarks by Juan Carlos Campo, a magistrate of the Constitutional Court who is leading its digital transformation. The court is studying how to bring AI into its work with strict limits. It will not use AI in the first screening of amparo petitions, the appeals by which people ask the court to protect their fundamental rights.
The refusal is not new. Público reported on 4 July that the Pleno had rejected, in an agreement of 10 June, a request from a lawyer’s association to study AI in deciding admission. Público gave the scale: in 2025 the court received 9,089 amparo petitions and admitted 59. By the agreement’s account, applications of AI may help with organising cases, finding precedent and summarising, but may not be used to judge whether a petition has special constitutional significance. As Moncloa reports him, Campo says a new nuance can alter the whole assessment of a case, so the weighing stays with the judges. The court also wants no black-box system and expects its own tools by spring 2027.
What we make of it
This part is our reflection, not the court’s. The line between finding and judging is clear on paper. In practice, a summary is already a reading. Whoever, or whatever, decides what to put first and what to leave out has begun the interpretive work, and the person who deliberates inherits that selection. In Hermeneutics in Common we ask how understanding is formed within relationship and tradition. A tool that condenses a case file takes part in forming that understanding, even when no one calls it a decision. The court speaks of tools used instrumentally. Whether an instrument can stay merely instrumental is the question we would put.
A proposed illustration
This is a hypothetical, not a real petition. A woman has lost a claim for a housing benefit through several levels. Her file is long. One paragraph, easy to compress away, records that the notice of refusal reached her after the deadline to appeal had already passed. A summary that leads with her main complaint and drops that paragraph may leave the judges with a weaker petition than the one she filed. No one decided against her, yet something was settled early.
What the sources do not say
They do not say how the court will check that summaries keep such details, or how a refused petitioner could learn that a person weighed the petition. Público quotes the agreement as saying review of an admission decision runs through a route the public prosecutor may use, which we read as leaving the petitioner without one; we have not read the statute. Moncloa’s report is secondary, and the Confilegal interview behind it was not available to us.
When the weighing is the part no one may delegate, what would let a person who was refused see that someone weighed?
Signed articles reflect the views of their authors. Corrections: info@dghumana.com.
